12 Comments
22 hrs agoLiked by Declan Finn

I've read Ringo & Kratman. Your remarks on them were solidly on the mark.

I never get excited about the woke critics. You can never make them happy. Why bother with their nonsense.

Expand full comment

And of course, there is Ivanova's "message" to the Clarke forces. God sent her!

Expand full comment
author

Yeah. I have to link in the previous article, since I made certain to put in the video ... okay, if I didn't, I will now.

Expand full comment
21 hrs agoLiked by Declan Finn

"I saw this on the Tor blog..."

You really didn't have to say anything else. That pretty much covered everything. At some point, the Martian Brain Fungus took over and they're just yet another left-wing avocation position for the Manhattan publishing scene.

Expand full comment
author

Yeah. But it was 8 years ago, I was trying to publish a bog every day. They were easy fodder. The repost is ... because I put a lot of work into that and I didn't want it eaten by whatever blogger is doing.

Expand full comment

The women in Gears of War (not 5, we don't count 5), games and novels, are nothing to forget either, but I'm sure Bourke and Tor do. Why do women like this get to comment on these things, and not the many of us ladies out here who are GWOT military veterans? 'Lived experience' and all that? Or does one only get to play that card when one has a certain point of view?

Expand full comment
author

100% the latter.

Expand full comment

I want to read the Ringo books just from the descriptions

Expand full comment
author

I will definitely push the "Special Circumstances" books, Princess of Wands et al.

Expand full comment

Women should not be in the special forces, ground-pounders or combat arms, full stop. The "Band of Bros & Hos" mixed sex war teams required by The Narrative are fake and grating. IRL? Nope.

But! And! SF&F has aliens, magic, and all manner of handwavium, so why not? Sure! Good fun even. Alas, the above toxic Narrative which hates humanity creates epic failures of natural human mindsets and sex differences, and the consequences thereof has poisoned much of the well. Sad.

And ! Also ! There are ultra-rare writers who understand that when the women are on the front line, performing combat ops, there's nothing left to lose. See The Night Witches (also all female) from history and Mech-Bunny. (Which nails it. Going to lobby hard for this one for the Dragon next year.)

So yes, Little Miss Torling is part of team "destroy fatherhood and families". So "No, sweetie, you're too dumb to know that what you are having a hissy fit about not only doesn't exist, but if it did, would be an improvement. You're so ignorant and toxic you can't even upgrade to 'wrong'..." is how I'd go.

But I won't, because Tor delenda est. Sorry Mr. Hartwell, the skinsuit has gone maggoty. Darn shame

Expand full comment

What they're upset about is that the portrayal of women in scifi hasn't yet made women as strong as men in real life.

Expand full comment

And this doesn't even get into Ringo's Black Tide Rising, where his books center around sisters Sofia and Faith. Especially Faith. Then there's Trans-Dimensional Hunter, the series he is currently co-writing with Lydia Sherrer where protagonist Lynn Raven is, in every sense the hero.

Expand full comment